AG百家乐在线官网

Analysis

Even after US strikes, Iran may still have the ability to make a nuclear bomb

US strikes could have halted Iran's ability to enrich the uranium needed to make a viable nuclear weapon. But that's not the same as preventing its ability to make a nuclear bomb.

FILE - This photo released Nov. 5, 2019, by the Atomic Energy Organization of Iran shows centrifuge machines in Natanz uranium enrichment facility near Natanz, Iran. A new underground facility at the Natanz enrichment site may put centrifuges beyond the range of a massive so-called ...bunker buster... bomb earlier developed by the U.S. military, according experts and satellite photos analyzed by The Associated Press in May 2023. (Atomic Energy Organization of Iran via AP, File)
Image: The facility near Natanz. File pic: Atomic Energy Organization of Iran via AP
Why you can trust Sky News

It would be sensible to wait until the dust has settled before judging whether the US strikes on Iran were, in Donald Trump's, words, "a spectacular military success".

And when dropping bombs that weigh more than 13 tonnes each, there's going to be a lot of dust.

The Pentagon says the operation against Iran's three largest nuclear facilities involved 125 military aircraft, warships and submarines, including the largest operational strike by B2 bombers in history.

Follow latest: Iran considering 'all options' after US strikes

The B-2s dropped 14 of America's most powerful GBU-57 "bunker buster" bombs on the Natanz uranium enrichment plant and Iran's most sophisticated nuclear facility at Fordow.

The first time, according to the Pentagon, the weapons have been used in a military operation.

The Fordow complex, buried deep in a mountain, was the only site not previously damaged by Israeli strikes over the last few days.

A GBU-57, or the Massive Ordnance Penetrator bomb, at Whiteman Air Base in Missouri. in 2023. File pic: US Air Force via AP
Image: A bunker-busting bomb. File pic: US Air Force via AP

The use of multiple GBU-57 bombs at Fordow is telling.

Despite their size, it was known that one of them would be insufficient to penetrate 80+ metres of solid rock believed to shelter Iran's most sophisticated uranium enrichment technology deep within Fordow.

Read more:
Fordow: What we know about Iran's secretive 'nuclear mountain'
What we know so far about US strikes on Iran's nuclear facilities

Satellite images reveal three visible holes at two different strike points on the mountainside above the complex.

A satellite image showing two clusters of holes at the Fordow nuclear site in Iran following US strikes on the facility. Pic: Maxar
Image: A satellite image showing two clusters of holes at the Fordow nuclear site in Iran following US strikes on the facility. Pic: Maxar

The sites appear to be close to what may have been ventilation shafts - possibly chosen to maximise damage below and render the facility useless.

Using several of the bombs in the same location is likely designed to allow each to penetrate further than the first before detonating.

If nuclear facilities at Isfahan, Natanz and Fordow were destroyed - as the US claims - or even crippled, it would certainly halt Iran's ability to enrich the Uranium needed to make a viable nuclear weapon.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Clarke: The dust will need to settle before we know true impact of US strikes

But that's not the same as preventing Iran's ability to make a nuclear bomb. To do that, they need "weapons-grade" uranium; the necessary metal-shaping, explosives and timing technology needed to trigger nuclear fission in the bomb; and a mechanism for delivering it.

The facilities targeted in the US raid are dedicated to achieving the first objective. Taking naturally occurring uranium ore, which contains around 0.7% uranium 235 - the isotope needed for nuclear fission - and concentrating it.

The centrifuges you hear about are the tools needed to enrich U-235 to the 90% purity needed for a compact "implosion"-type warhead that can be delivered by a missile.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Iranian media: 'Part of Fordow' attacked

And the reality is Iran's centrifuges have been spinning for a long time.

United Nations nuclear inspectors warned in May that Iran had at least 408kg of uranium "enriched" to 60%.

Getting to that level represents 90% of the time and effort to get to 90% U-235. And those 400kg would yield enough of that weapons-grade uranium to make nine nuclear weapons, the inspectors concluded.

The second element is something Iran has also been working on for two decades.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

'US strikes won't end Iran's nuclear programme'

Precisely shaping uranium metal and making shaped explosive charges to crush it in the right way to achieve "criticality", the spark for the sub-atomic chain reaction that releases the terrifying energy in a nuclear explosion.

In its recent bombing campaign, Israel is thought to have targeted facilities where Iranian nuclear scientists were doing some of that work.

Analysis on the US strikes:
Trump's two big gambles as US enters war with Iran

For Trump, the performative presidency just got real

But unlike the industrial processes needed to enrich uranium, these later steps can be carried out in laboratory-sized facilities. Easier to pack up and move, and easier to hide from prying eyes.

16 cargo trucks line up at the entrance of the Fordow nuclear site on 19 June. Pic: Maxar Technologies
Image: 16 cargo trucks line up at the entrance of the Fordow nuclear site on 19 June. Pic: Maxar Technologies

Given that it's understood Iran already moved enriched uranium out of Fordow ahead of the US strike, it's far from certain that Iran has, in fact, lost its ability to make a bomb.

And while the strikes may have delayed the logistics, it's possible they've emboldened a threatened Iran to intensify its warhead-making capability if it does still have one.

Making a more compact implosion-based warhead is not easy. There is debate among experts about how advanced Iran is along that road.

Be the first to get Breaking News

Install the Sky News app for free

But if it felt sufficiently motivated, it does have other, less sophisticated nuclear options.

Even 60% enriched uranium, of which - remember - it has a lot, can be coaxed to criticality in a much larger, cruder nuclear device.

Follow The World
Follow The World

Listen to The World with Richard Engel and Yalda Hakim every Wednesday

This wouldn't pose as much threat to its enemies, as it would be too heavy to fit on even the best of Iran's long-range missiles.

But it would, nonetheless, elevate Iran to the status of a nuclear power.